Welcome to Campus Pollyeyes
Campus Pollyeyes, located at 339 S Blanchard St in Findlay, Ohio, is a beloved destination for pizza aficionados and breadstick enthusiasts alike. Known for its warm, inviting atmosphere and excellent service, this eatery serves up an array of delicious offerings, including their signature stuffed breadsticks that are praised for their buttery texture and generous fillings. Customers rave about the pizza, particularly the thin crust and flavorful toppings, complemented by a house-made ranch dipping sauce that becomes an instant favorite. With a rich history linked to the Pagliai family legacy, Campus Pollyeyes continues to delight patrons with its commitment to quality and tradition.
-
339 S Blanchard St, Findlay, OH 45840, United States Hotline: +1 567-525-5539
Welcome to the delightful world of Campus Pollyeyes, a cherished gem nestled in Findlay, Ohio. Located at 339 S Blanchard St, this establishment has earned a reputation for its delicious offerings and warm service, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. Whether you’re passing through town or are a local, Campus Pollyeyes promises a dining experience that feels both familiar and exceptional.
One cannot mention Campus Pollyeyes without highlighting their world-famous stuffed breadsticks. These aren’t your average breadsticks; they are a buttery, savory delight packed with melted cheese and your choice of toppings, creating an explosion of flavors in every bite. Customers rave about their mouthwatering experience—like Bigol Nutsak, who found their stuffed sticks to be a life-changing encounter that left him yearning for more.
The pizza here is another standout feature. Reviews consistently commend the crispiness of the original crust and the generous toppings. Many patrons, including Dan Cooper, find a connection to the rich legacy of the Pagliai family and reminisce about their childhood experiences with pizza that brings nostalgia alongside delight. And with a menu that emphasizes quality and portion size, it's no wonder that diners leave satisfied.
In addition to their food, Campus Pollyeyes boasts a casual, friendly atmosphere. Customers frequently mention the attentive service, as exemplified by the glowing reviews praising the staff, including personal anecdotes reflecting the team’s dedication and charm. This welcoming vibe invites you to linger a little longer, whether for a quick takeout or a leisurely meal with friends and family.
As you step into Campus Pollyeyes, prepare to embark on a flavor journey that pays homage to classic pizza traditions while adding its unique twist. The harmonious blend of quality ingredients, expert preparation, and genuine service make this restaurant an unforgettable stop for anyone with a passion for food. Don't miss the chance to experience their delicious offerings; your taste buds will thank you!
The stuffed sticks were amazing, they’re buttery breadsticks with cheese and two toppings of your choice inside. The pizza was also very good, as well as the house made ranch dipping sauce. Will definitely visit again when traveling through.
Pizza and service were great. I highly recommend! History lesson: I grew up in Charleston, IL with Pagliai’s Pizza. It is a VERY popular local pizza place. Imagine my surprise when I pass through Findlay, OH and Google a pizza place. Campus Pollyeyes came up and I couldn’t resist. Miss Scarlett was my server and just happens to be the owners daughter. I made my order and started asking Scarlett questions about the possibility of a connection between the Findlay and Charleston locations. She knew some of the Findlay origin (two brothers started the pizza place) but that was about it. While eating, I started researching. Pagliai’s in Findlay changed the name to Pollyeyes as a more phonetic way to pronounce the name. It turns out my suspicions were correct. There was a third brother who went to Illinois and started up the one in Charleston. The pizza tastes similar, but not exact to what I grew up with. Really took me down memory lane. The Pagliai family still owns the pizza place in Charleston, but is not the case in Ohio. I am super proud to say that Scarlett and her family are doing a great job carrying on the Pagliai tradition of great pizza. Guess what... I’m coming back through Findlay tomorrow evening. Guess where I’m going?
We usually get takeout, but the atmosphere is casual. The service is good and food is great. Pizzas, subs, and their stuffed breadsticks are our favorite!
service was really attentive and on point. facilities were clean and maintained food was a little pricey but for the taste and portion size it is well worth the cost. The findlay location is small compared to a chain restaurant but even to seat a high school football team . i would well recommend this establishment for a great meal and friendly gathering.
I’ve been consuming food ever since I was a little boy... and never in my 46 years have I ever had my mind blown away and my stomach pleased nearly as much as after I consumed my meal at campus pollyeyes in Findlay tonight. I’ve heard my friends talk about it before but I’ve never been into the store to try it. I’m also quite the pizza buff, I’ve had some of the top pizza locations in the country, from authentic New York style pizza from pizza shops in the big Apple, to some of the greasiest deep dish places in the windy city(Chicago). But after tonight I’ve decided I may never grace another pizza restaurant in my life. What do I recommend? Well for starters, the stuffed breadsticks are divine. The portion sizes make it well worth your money first off, and the taste is unmatched, as they give you mouthful after mouthful of savory mozzarella cheese along with your choice of topping, basted in their delicious buttery garlic sauce. And don’t even get me started on their ranch... let’s just say I ordered myself multiple quarts to take home for myself... then, they brought out the pizza. And oh goodness. I decided to be simplistic, going with just pepperoni and extra cheese, for my first time. But simplistic wouldn’t even be in the first thousand words I’d use to describe this delicacy. My taste buds felt as if they had died and ascended into heaven. My eyes filled with tears as I experienced a joy I hadn’t experienced since I was a wee lad. Safe to say I’m thoroughly looking forward to eating my leftovers tomorrow and the following day. As well as phenomenal food... the staff was amazing too. All I interacted with were kind, helpful, and personable. I couldn’t have asked for a better dining experience, and I feel lucky to have been introduced into this blessing.
Stuffed breadsticks are truly AMAZING!! Original crust was thin and perfectly cooked. Excited about trying the thick crust next time!
Was in BG this weekend. Was going to stop at Campus Pollyeyes there, but with recent issues with staff and unprofessional management at that location, we decided to stop in Findlay. Glad we did! Service was outatanding, the store was very clean, and the food was awesome! We ordered 2 3-piece orders of stuffed breadsticks. One order with sausage, green olive, and onion. The 2nd order was pepperoni and green olive. Both were outstanding! While we travel to BG frequently, this will be our new location to stop at. Thanks for the great meal yesterday!
Amazing Food, Great Staff, Clean Facility Nothing is better than having a great meal with a friendly staff taking care of you. Highly recommend the World Famous Bread Sticks!!